Article 51 of the United Nations Charter guarantees its members "the inherent right to…individual self defense" against "an armed attack." In January of 2006, Hamas was elected to govern the Palestinian Authority. After Israel ended its occupation of Gaza and removed all of its settlers, Hamas threw the Palestinian Authority out of the Gaza and assumed de facto as well as de jure control over the entire Gaza Strip. Its leaders then instructed its military wing to direct rockets at civilian targets in southern Israel. At first these rockets were Qassams with a relatively short range. Now they include Katyushas, which can reach to Israel's large cities, including Ashkelon, with its population of 120,000 civilians. Hamas has officially declared that its policy is to develop or smuggle even longer range missiles capable of reaching Israel's largest city Tel Aviv and its lifeblood, Ben Gurion Airport. It has promised to keep aiming its missiles at civilian targets until the Jewish state is finally destroyed.
If this is not an "armed attack" under Article 51, then I don't know what is. The only argument against it being an armed attack is that rocketing civilian population centers, as Hamas is doing, is a war-crime. International law prohibits, even during a declared war, the deliberate targeting of civilians or the bombing of areas of civilian population centers with absolutely no military significance. But war-crimes may also constitute an armed attack: Hitler's invasion of Poland was both, as the Nuremberg Tribunal determined. If anything, an armed attack that is also a war crime justifies the right of self defense even more than a mere armed attack.
...
The time has come for Israel's critics to tell Israel what it should do in the face of these escalating rocket attacks on its civilian population centers. If economic sanctions, border controls, targeting terrorists and ground incursions should not be done, what are the alternatives?
- Enjoy this article? Help vote it up the 'Vine.
- Public Discussion (1)
Hamas has been declaring war against Israel for years--and before Hamas, it was Arafat and his cronies. Israel has every right, beyond any UN charter, to defend itself.
The antisemites on Newsvine will say it is Fascist for Israel to even exist. I wonder what they would do if their homes were suddenly bombarded with rockets; if their families were threatened with suicide bombers; if they lived in constant uncertainty.
I would want my government to fight back--to take whatever means necessary to protect its citizens and bring an end to the violence.
Thanks for the article. Hamas is, indeed, guilty of many war-crimes. This will only continue. Peace talks will only prolong the bloodshed.
- 2 votes
You're in Easy Mode. If you prefer, you can use XHTML Mode instead. |



