Newsvine
  • Welcome
  • Help
  • Report Bug
  • Conversation Tracker
  • Your Column
  • Replies
  • Friends
Type Comments Since You Last CheckedArticle Source Last Checked Stop Tracking All Clear Tracking All
advertisement
Log In | Register
Close the Login Panel
Existing users log in below. New users please register for a free account.

New Users:

Existing Users:

E-Mail:
Password:
Forgot Password?
Please enter the e-mail address or domain name you registered with:
E-Mail/Domain:
Back to Login
Log Out
  • Top News
  • Local News
  • World
  • U.S.
  • Sports
  • Politics
  • Tech
  • Entertainment
  • Science
  • Business
  • Health
  • Odd News
  • More
    • Arts
    • Education
    • Environment
    • Fashion
    • History
    • Home & Garden
    • Not News
    • Religion
    • Travel
Visit Yaakov's column >>

YAAKOV

Home Page
Ponderings and Links on Israel and Jewish Issues and Technology
Articles Posted: 72  Links Seeded: 601
Member Since: 1/2006  Last Seen: 12/04/2011

What is Newsvine?

Updated continuously by citizens like you, Newsvine is an instant reflection of what the world is talking about at any given moment.

Get a Free Account
Help
Fun Stuff
  • Your Clippings
  • Leaderboard
  • E-Mail Alerts
  • Top of the Vine
  • Newsvine Live
  • Newsvine Archives
  • The Greenhouse
  • Recommended Articles
  • Wall of Vineness
Put a Seed Newsvine link on your own site

How Can Israel Become a Better Democracy?

Wed Jul 9, 2008 3:06 AM EDT
world-news, israel, middle-east, government, supreme-court, democracy, knesset, personal-rights
By Yaakov
advertisement

Israel is known as the best democracy in the Middle East. This is a true statement. Compared to all of its neighbors, the personal freedoms afforded to citizens in Israel far surpass those given to citizens in neighboring countries. However, this does not mean that Israel is perfect in this respect. Far from it. Coming from the US, I have noticed and been bothered by aspects of the US system of governance that are missing in Israel, resulting mainly in unrestrained abuses of power and corruption in certain branches of the government. Below is my list of five changes that could be made to the way that the government runs in Israel, the implementation of which would make Israel into a more complete democracy and a better place to live.

  1. Supreme Court: The Judicial sector needs some definition as to its scope of power. Some form of checks and balances. In the US, supreme court justices are appointed by the Executive Branch, and must be affirmed by the Legislative branch. In Israel, the supreme court justices appoint their own successors, declare what their power is, what their jurisdiction is, meddle in political decision-making, and answer to no one. Justice Secretary Friedmann is doing something to try to curtail this, but there is still a long way to go.
  2. Direct Legislative Election: Most Israeli citizens today despise the government (or at least do not approve of its continued existence). Yet, somehow, it remains in power. One of the factors in play is that the leading party is supported by a coalition or other parties. Each party is free to make deals, receiving money or power in order to help keep Kadimah propped up. And the individual legislators are answerable to no one. In the US, where congressman and senators represent specific people, if those people no longer like the job that their representative is doing, they vote them out of office. Not so in Israel. Here, no one is directly elected. Instead, everyone votes for specific parties. Those parties have central committees which decide who will be on the party list. It is a very confusing system, where a criminal like Chaim Ramon is able to become the next-in-line to the Prime Ministership merely because he is friends with Olmert (the same way that Olmert got into power as well). And people like Eli Yishai and Ehud Barak are guarunteed to hold onto their power, regardless of how many people disaprove of their actions (yes, I know that their own parties membership can throw them out, but the system is built to make this hard to do). Until Knesset representatives are answerable for their actions, there will be no end to members and parties in the Knesset acting to further their own power while sacrificing the security and well-being of the country.
  3. Equal Enforcement of the Law: Enforce the law equally, in all sectors. That means against both settlers and Israelis who live in pre-1967 Israel, against Jews, Arabs and Christians, and in both East and West Jerusalem. Free speech for all (and not just for those who the Supreme Court or current ruling party favors).
  4. Cabinet Members Cannot be Knesset Members: Today, the positions in the cabinet are given out by the Prime Minister to the ruling members of his coalition parties as a reward for supporting the government's coalition. This leads to ill-suited cabinet appointments (anyone remember who the defense minister was during the Second Lebanon War) as well as misuse of Cabinet positions. Cabinet positions are extremely powerful - the secretaries of the different government ministries have the ability to positively and negatively affect nearly all aspects of life in the country. The Prime Minister and his government should have every right to fill these positions; however, these appointments should be based on the appointees ability to fill the office and expertly run his/her ministry - they should not be based on political gamesmanship and cronyism.
  5. Constitution: Israel needs a constitution. Right now, there is none, and therefore there are no clear legal principles guiding what rights the government has, what rights people have. It is based on a mish-mash of laws inherited from British Common law and the US, along with the Basic Law, but there are no defined standards. Is Israel a Jewish state or a Democracy? Search and Seizure? Are there any standard rights that all citizens have? Whether or not today's secular state is to be ruled by Torah and halacha is a separate issue. Is there to be an equivalent of the US Bill of Rights? But at least have something clearly defined. Nearly all of the above issues would be solved if Israel had a constitution that was accepted and observed to the degree that the same document is in the United States.
  • Enjoy this article? Help vote it up the 'Vine.

Back To Top | Front Page

Published to:

  • Yaakov's Column, All of Newsvine
  • Groups: Israel Talk, Open Source Intelligence, Utopia, Worldviews
  • Regions: none
  • Public Discussion (19)
Dennis P. McCannDeleted
MarcusK

Very interesting article... there are 2 things though, while:

Israel is known as the best democracy in the Middle East. This is a true statement.

I would agree (I hope I am not hung for saying that), I would disagree with :

Compared to all of its neighbors, the personal freedoms afforded to citizens in Israel far surpass those given to citizens in neighboring countries.

There is the exception of Lebanon, though for most others the comment holds true.

Otherwise, very interesting and accurate article. I am sure most countries, developing themselves, benefit greatly by following your points.

  • 2 votes
Reply#2 - Wed Jul 9, 2008 6:47 AM EDT
Yaakov

There is the exception of Lebanon, though for most others the comment holds true.

Do you disagree with my use of the expression "far surpass"? Or do you think that Lebanon affords its citizens greater personal freedoms? Care to back that up? While this may be partially true with the theoretical government "in control" of the country, with Hizballah in running parts of the capital and the whole Southern section of the country as their own police state while being supported by Iran and Syria and amassing arms to launch a coup and/or attack Israel, I think that the actual freedoms afforded to all Lebanese citizens are greatly drawn back from what they could be in Hizballah's absence.

  • 6 votes
#2.1 - Wed Jul 9, 2008 6:57 AM EDT
MarcusK

Well, I am Lebanese, and I have not once felt I can not say or do what I wished, within the law of course.

As for the comment about the "theoretical government" and outside influences, I could not agree more.

However, actual freedoms are there. My statement stands true. Unfortunately, and this is a point I have been criticized over, constantly, the problem is the People, not the government. or as I read in an article over the 'vine, the Sheeple.

I think that the actual freedoms afforded to all Lebanese citizens are greatly drawn back from what they could be in Hizballah's absence.

I would simply disagree with the opening part. it would be accurate to say (and this is my opinion)

"all Lebanese citizens are greatly drawn back from what they could be in Hizballah's absence."

But let us not go about a separate political debate in this article, which I truly find commendable. Should you wish to elaborate on the other issue, we can set up a specific place for it.

I merely wished to clarify, that in terms of personal freedom, Lebanon was not far!

  • 4 votes
#2.2 - Wed Jul 9, 2008 7:21 AM EDT
Yaakov

I merely wished to clarify, that in terms of personal freedom, Lebanon was not far!

Fair enough, point taken.

  • 2 votes
#2.3 - Wed Jul 9, 2008 7:33 AM EDT
MarcusK

:) I have been called many names for pointing the finger inwards rather than southwards.

Most importantly, I would never disagree with logic.

And as far as I can tell, throughout your articles, not only do you present logical arguments, but are right on the money too.

  • 3 votes
#2.4 - Wed Jul 9, 2008 7:59 AM EDT
Eric AlbertDeleted
Reply
Scipio AfricanusDeleted
spiffie

Good to see you back, Yaakov, and a very nice article.

  • 3 votes
Reply#4 - Wed Jul 9, 2008 1:45 PM EDT
Scipio AfricanusDeleted
ehad aham

Great article.

  • 2 votes
Reply#6 - Wed Jul 9, 2008 2:14 PM EDT
Jared Kardos

Great article, very informative. I didn't know just about any of that.

Kudos, good sir. :)

  • 1 vote
Reply#7 - Wed Jul 9, 2008 4:48 PM EDT
Conservative CriticDeleted
xDrudge

Yaakov
Such a brave article. Bravo!

  • 3 votes
Reply#9 - Thu Jul 10, 2008 12:34 PM EDT
Sedekka

Yes a very brave article. Thanks for the lesson. Cheers.

    #9.1 - Sun Jul 13, 2008 2:06 AM EDT
    Reply
    Leave a Comment:
    You're in Easy Mode. If you prefer, you can use XHTML Mode instead.
    You're in XHTML Mode. If you prefer, you can use Easy Mode instead.
    (XHTML tags allowed - a,b,blockquote,br,code,dd,dl,dt,del,em,h2,h3,h4,i,ins,li,ol,p,pre,q,strong,ul)
    Newsvine Privacy Statement
    As a new user, you may notice a few temporary content restrictions. Click here for more info.
    FUN STUFF:
    • Leaderboard |
    • E-Mail Alerts |
    • Top of the Vine |
    • Newsvine Live |
    • Newsvine Archives |
    • The Greenhouse |
    COMPANY STUFF:
    • Code of Honor |
    • Company Info |
    • Contact Us |
    • Jobs |
    • User Agreement |
    • Privacy Policy |
    • About our ads
    LEGAL STUFF:
    • © 2005-2012 Newsvine, Inc. |
    • Newsvine® is a registered trademark of Newsvine, Inc. |
    • Newsvine is a property of msnbc.com